• Track Record
    of Success

    As one of Orange County's premier criminal firms, we've successfully handled hundreds of cases.

    Read About Our Victories
  • Trusted &
    Experienced

    Let the words of our past clients help you decide if we are the right law firm to represent you.

    Client Testimonials
  • Accused of
    Domestic Abuse?

    We are familiar with defending against false accusations. Our firm knows how to build a solid defense.

    Accomplished Defense
  • Contact Our
    Office Today

    We know every case is unique, which is why we offer representation tailored to meet your needs.

    Protect Yourself

Jose Ines Garcia Zarate Acquittal

At the end of November, a jury in San Francisco acquitted Jose Ines Garcia Zarate of the murder of Kate Steinle. As anyone who has not been living under a rock for the last month knows, uproar ensued. The case has drawn uncommon national attention, ostensibly because the accused was an undocumented immigrant who had previously been deported and convicted of illegally re-entering the country (though as is often the case when local criminal cases grab unwarranted national headlines, it certainly helped that the victim was an attractive young white woman). When the jury returned an acquittal not just as to the 1st degree murder as charged, but also the lesser included charge of manslaughter, only convicting Zarate of the illegal possession of the firearm used in the homicide, the Build the Wall crowd predictably lost their feeble minds.

Both Trump and his Confederacy loving flunky Jeff Sessions criticized the jury’s verdict as a travesty of justice. I am not writing today to defend the verdict as correct. I do not frankly know enough about the facts of the case to weigh in on whether I agree with the verdict (although I recognize that the optics and emotions of a case like this do not generally set the stage for an acquittal and that the jury certainly did not make what would have been the easier choice lending a lot of credibility to their verdict in my mind). Instead, I write today to talk about some of the common nonsense that gets spewed when an acquittal upsets the law and order folks.

POP QUIZ!

A criminal jury trial is:

  1. About justice for the victims
  2. A search for the truth
  3. None of the above

If you picked C, you might have been awake in your high school civics class!

A criminal jury is about one thing and one thing only: whether the government can present sufficient admissible evidence to prove the accusations it has made beyond a reasonable doubt. That’s it. If it can, the defendant is convicted. If it cannot, the defendant is found Not Guilty, which anyone paying attention has a very different meaning than Innocent.

So a criminal jury trial is neither about justice for a victim nor is it a search for the truth. This is underscored by who the plaintiff is in a criminal case: The People a/k/a society at large. The plaintiff is not the victim of the crime. In a civil case, where a person can seek justice for wrongs committed against them, the named plaintiff IS the alleged victim.

In addition, a criminal jury trial is an opportunity to “figure out what happened” or “search for the truth” as prosecutors are fond of suggesting. By the time a criminal case proceeds to trial, the search should be over. By the time of trial. the government has searched and decided they believe they can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused committed the crimes they are charged with. The jury is there for one and only one reason: to tell the government whether they have done so or not.

That is all that happened in San Francisco, a jury told the government: sorry, not good enough.

  • Track Record
    of Success

    As one of Orange County's premier criminal firms, we've successfully handled hundreds of cases.

    Read About Our Victories
  • Trusted &
    Experienced

    Let the words of our past clients help you decide if we are the right law firm to represent you.

    Client Testimonials
  • Accused of
    Domestic Abuse?

    We are familiar with defending against false accusations. Our firm knows how to build a solid defense.

    Accomplished Defense
  • Contact Our
    Office Today

    We know every case is unique, which is why we offer representation tailored to meet your needs.

    Protect Yourself

Contact Us

Law Office of Frances Prizzia
Orange County Criminal Defense Attorney
Located at: 5000 Birch Street,
Suite 3000,

Newport Beach, CA 92660
View Map
Phone: (888) 392-8114
Local Phone: (714) 248-8661
Website:
© 2018 All Rights Reserved.

Disclaimer

The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.