What Proof Do You Need for a Restraining Order

Law Offices of Frances Prizzia
What proof do you need for a restraining order

A restraining order can provide safety and peace of mind for those facing threats, abuse, or harassment. To obtain one, the petitioner must show evidence that supports the request. Courts rely on proof to determine if issuing an order is necessary to protect you.

Frances Prizzia Criminal Defense Lawyers defends those who have been targeted by restraining orders. Whether you're dealing with allegations of domestic violence, harassment, or workplace threats, we defend your rights.

Understanding the type of evidence required is key to defending your case. From personal testimony to police reports, every detail matters. 

Types of Restraining Orders

Restraining orders are legal tools to protect individuals from threats, harassment, or abuse. In Orange County, there are different types of restraining orders to suit specific situations. Each order has its own requirements and purpose, with many providing legal and police protection.

Some of the main types of restraining orders are:

Domestic Violence Restraining Orders

A Domestic Violence Restraining Order is for people facing harm or threats from someone they have a close relationship with. This includes spouses, ex-partners, family members, or cohabitants. It protects individuals from physical abuse, harassment, or threats.

Accusers must provide evidence of current or past abuse, such as messages, photos, or police reports. A temporary restraining order may be issued immediately if the risk is urgent. The court then holds a permanent restraining order hearing to decide if further protection is needed. We can represent you at your hearing to show why this restraining order is not necessary.

Civil Harassment Restraining Orders

A Civil Harassment Restraining Order is for individuals who are not closely related to the person accused of the harassment. This could include neighbors, coworkers, or acquaintances. The person seeking protection must show evidence of harassment, such as stalking, threats, or intimidation.

These orders require proof of abuse or harassment that caused emotional or physical harm. A temporary restraining order may be issued while the court reviews the evidence. Civil harassment cases often involve building a strong case to ensure long-term protection. We will make sure your rights are respected as the case unfolds.

Workplace Violence Restraining Orders

Employers can request a Workplace Violence Restraining Order to protect employees from threats or harassment on the job. This type of restraining order is designed to prevent workplace threats, such as stalking, physical harm, or intimidation.

Employers must show that an employee has experienced harm or is at risk. Evidence such as witness statements, emails, or security footage can support the request. This order ensures the safety of workers and creates a safer work environment.

Standard of Proof Required

Standard of proof required

To obtain a restraining order, petitioners must meet specific standards of proof. This means providing enough evidence to convince the court that protection is necessary. The standard of proof depends on the type of restraining order and the circumstances of the case.

Here are the two common standards of proof required in restraining order cases:

The Preponderance of the Evidence

The preponderance of the evidence standard requires the accuser to show that it is more likely than not that harassment or abuse occurred. This means the evidence must show a greater than 50% chance that the claims are true. This standard is often used in civil restraining order cases.

Examples of evidence include messages, witness statements, or photos of injuries. The court looks at all evidence to determine if issuing the order is justified. Meeting this standard is usually enough to secure a temporary restraining order or long-term protection.

Clear and Convincing Evidence

The clear and convincing evidence standard is higher than preponderance but lower than proof beyond a reasonable doubt. This standard requires the accuser to provide strong and reliable evidence that the claims are highly likely to be true. It applies in cases involving serious matters, like domestic violence or threats.

Evidence must be detailed and consistent, such as police reports, medical records, or recordings of threats. The court examines the evidence to ensure it clearly supports the need for protection. Meeting this standard is critical for obtaining a permanent restraining order.

Types of Evidence to Support a Restraining Order Request

When filing for a restraining order, presenting strong evidence is essential. The court relies on this evidence to determine whether protection is necessary.

A few of the main types of evidence commonly used in restraining order cases include:

Personal Testimony and Witness Testimonies

Personal testimony is one of the strongest pieces of evidence in a restraining order case. It allows the accuser to tell the court, in detail, what happened. To be convincing, the accuser must include dates, locations, and specific incidents of abuse or harassment. The court will consider how the events impacted your safety and emotional well-being.

Witness testimonies are equally important. If someone saw the harassment or its effects, their statement can back up the accuser's claims. Witnesses could include neighbors who overheard arguments, coworkers who saw threatening messages, or family members aware of past incidents. Their accounts give the court a fuller picture of what occurred.

Because there are so many types of evidence, you need a reliable, strong, and experienced criminal defense attorney to defend your case and show the court why this restraining order is not necessary.

Communication Records

Communication records, such as text messages, emails, voicemails, and social media messages, are vital evidence in restraining order cases. These records can show the court the harasser’s actions, whether they involve threats, intimidation, or repeated unwanted contact.

For instance, threatening texts or emails can demonstrate the severity of the harassment. Repeated calls or voicemails might show a pattern of behavior that causes distress. Even messages with abusive language can help support the case. If harassment occurs through social media, screenshots of messages or comments can serve as proof.

We will meticulously review all evidence of communication in your case. It is important for us to get out in front of the narrative and use the communication to show why the restraining order against you is not necessary.

Medical Records

Medical records are critical in cases involving actual physical harm. They provide concrete evidence of injuries caused by abuse or harassment. X-rays, lab tests, and images of bruises can be used against you.

In addition to proving physical harm, medical records can also show emotional distress. Therapy or counseling records may demonstrate the psychological toll of the abuse. This evidence reinforces the seriousness of the situation and strengthens the case against you.

We will review all medical records and look for alternative explanations. Just because someone got hurt does not mean a restraining order is necessary. We will build a convincing story and help you craft the strongest possible defense.

Police Reports

Police reports are among the strongest forms of evidence in restraining order cases. If the accuser reported the harassment or abuse to law enforcement, their official documentation can be used in a case against you. Police reports often include details about the incident, statements from both parties and any actions taken by officers, such as arrests.

For example, if the police responded to a domestic violence incident, their report may describe the injuries, property damage, or threats made during the event. This information can be crucial for the case if officers issue a temporary restraining order or file charges.

These reports also provide a neutral, third-party account of what happened. Courts rely on police reports because they are considered credible and impartial. We will review the police reports, look for inconsistencies in the evidence, and build a strong defense on your behalf.

Steps to Strengthen Your Case

Steps to strengthen your case

If you want to improve your defense against a restraining order, there are a few steps to follow. Each step helps you gather the proof the court needs to make a decision.

  1. Write Down What Happened: Keep a clear record of every incident. Include dates, times, places, and details about what the person did or said. This helps the court understand your version of the story.
  2. Save Messages and Calls: Keep any texts, emails, voicemails, or social media messages. These give us a chance to build an alternative version of the story when compared to the accuser.
  3. Take Photos or Videos: If you were hurt in any incident with the accuser, take photos or videos of your injuries. We can use these photos to build an alternative narrative.
  4. Get Witness Statements: If someone saw or heard the harassment, ask them to write what they saw. Their words could back up your version of events.
  5. Seek Medical Help if Injured: If you were hurt, see a doctor. Medical records can show that you also got hurt in the incident and shift the narrative.
  6. Get Legal Advice: Work with an experienced lawyer who can help you prepare. We will make sure you have all the right documents and evidence for court.
  7. Stay Organized: Keep all your evidence in one place. This includes your notes, photos, messages, police reports, and medical records. Being organized makes it easier to present your case.

Following these steps can help you build a strong case and show the court why you need protection.

FAQs

What is a temporary restraining order?

A temporary restraining order (TRO) is a short-term court order designed to protect someone from harm or harassment. It provides immediate safety until a court hearing determines if a long-term order is necessary. Temporary restraining order requests are common in cases of domestic violence or sexual assault.

A temporary restraining order expires after a court hearing, usually within 20 to 25 days. At the hearing, the court will decide whether to issue a long-term restraining order for extended protection.

Temporary restraining orders require basic evidence to show harassment, abuse, or threats. This could include messages, photos, witness statements, or police reports. Courts typically grant TROs with such a low threshold of evidence because the priority is immediate safety.

Call Our Orange County Lawyer for a Free Consultation

Call our Orange County lawyer for a free consultation

If you’re dealing with allegations of harassment, threats, or abuse, we’re here to help. Frances Prizzia Criminal Defense Lawyers understand how overwhelming these situations can be. Our team is ready to provide you with the strong defense you deserve.

A permanent civil restraining order can have a major impact on your life. We believe everyone is innocent until proven guilty, and we are here to defend your rights. Contact us today for a free consultation.

Call us about your case today at
(714) 362-0157 for a
Free Confidential Consultation.

Search Our Site
Our Newport Beach
Location
5000 Birch Street, Suite 3000
Newport Beach, CA 92660

Why Choose
Frances Prizzia Criminal Defense Lawyers

1

Client Centered Approach

Our clients are our priority, we listen & have your best interests in mind. Our philosophy is that crime is simply a symptom of a bigger issue that should be addressed.
2

Reputation by Excellence

"Top 100 Trial Lawyers" by the National Trial Lawyers and Clients' Choice by Avvo.
3

Experience

Over 19+ Years of Criminal Defense Experience on your side.
4

Innovative & Determined

We think outside the box and never leave a stone unturned.
5

You're Not Just Another Client

You're in a difficult situation that requires attention. Our boutique legal team walks you through the legal process so you don't feel lost.
6

AVAILABLE FOR YOU NOW

We are available 24/7 for emergencies & offer free confidential consultations.
fill out the form
Request Your Free
Confidential Consultation

"*" indicates required fields

Full Name*
Required Fields *
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
chevron-downarrow-leftarrow-right